A big change occurred with the introduction of the Smith and Wesson Military and Police .38 revolver. Smith & Wesson 686 One of the most popular revolvers in production, the Smith & Wesson 686 revolver is a medium (“L frame”) revolver chambered in the powerful .357 Magnum caliber. Your email address will not be published. That first Paterson was a five-shot, cap-and-ball revolver. Colt’s revolvers such as the New Pocket featured a swing out cylinder, cylinder latch that pulled to the rear, and a smooth double action trigger. After the war, both companies manufactured distinctive revolvers. Various models of the, Tournament News & Results – Bass, Walleye, Crappie, Redfish and More. I am a retired P.O. Colt Python 357 Magnum (1988), $2500. Carried in custom made Buscalero gunbelt. The .38 Colt was a dismal failure in action in the Philippines and at home. The two systems are often confused, but that’s an issue for another day. Today we’ll talk about revolvers embellished by Tiffany & Co. Sam Colt invented the revolver as we know it, offering the first one for sale in 1836. He agreed. But this was a time when Colt pretty well ruled the roost with the Peacemaker in its many chamberings. Howdy all, I’ve had the notion for a while to buy a 4 inch 44 magnum revolver. I’d love to have a Colt Python but they’ve become insanely priced for me. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. He told me that he would not flip for the difference between the two. The first is double-action, and the second is single-action. An earlier—and very complicated—flintlock revolver, the Collier, came out of the United Kingdom and may or may not have had some influence on the young Yankee entrepreneur. I was broke and went to the bank and begged the banker for a $125.00 30 day loan. It was first designed with a 158-grain semi-jacketed soft point( flat) bullet. Trigger pressure would cause the hammer to come fully back, as the cylinder revolved around to index with the barrel. Much of that movement was on horseback, where the one-handed repeater was ideal. I think that while the revolvers looked similar and handled the same, there were differences in the grip and trigger action that had appeal to different shooters. Consequently I sold it for more than I paid, but now wish I’d kept it just for the value aspect. 27 Posts #21 • Jun 1, 2017. I prefer smith and Wesson, but both are great choices. When shopping for a handgun, the Smith and Wesson revolvers for sale online are the first on the list for a good reason. It was introduced in 1896 for Smith & Wesson's first-model Hand Ejector revolver. When we went to his car he open the trunk and gave me the Nickle Plated 4 inch Python, a fancy tooled belt and holster, two boxes of ammo, a pair of handcuffs, and a can of del defend. Three years before the more conventional.38-caliber K-Frame, S&W had introduced the I-Frame. Earlier this weekend, I was doing some cleaning and organizing, and two similar, yet very different, revolvers ended up side by side. Essentially, the question that has to be answered is, Would we be willing to settle for the Smith & Wesson? Smith and Wesson lengthened the .38 Long Colt cartridge slightly and improved performance from a 152-grain bullet at 750 fps to a 158-grain bullet at 850 fps. When I am hiking or traveling around Appalachia, the Blue Ridge, and the Smokies, I sometimes find myself in the vicinity of feral dogs and other dangerous wildlife. The only Colt that is superior to similar Smith & Wesson models is the Detective Special which is the best snub for the purpose. By continuing to browse our website you agree to our use of cookies. The problem was that these frame codenames became so prolific that they started getting used to describe any and all revolvers – even those not made by Smith & Wesson. Various models of the Colt revolver followed, each offering improvements of one kind or the other. The Colt revolver had to be designed to stabilize the firing hand to allow thumb cocking and to present the sights for proper aiming. When Colt’s patent expired in the mid-1850s, it opened the door for rigorous competition from other manufacturers, such as Smith & Wesson … They’ll never leave the family . The U.S. Army asked for a revolver more robust than the Colt 1892 and a more powerful cartridge. Plus an M&P 15, NATO, and on and on. One firm might be ahead in sales on the strength of a new innovation, as when Colt introduced an aluminum-frame revolver for concealed carry. Several of its guns—like the break-top Schofield—were used and respected. Today, those who appreciate old iron are happy to find either revolver at a fair price. All are great guns but the Pythons are my favorites . The Smith & Wesson was a smallbore version of the L-frame 686 revolver, and the Ruger was the smallbore brother to the New Model Super Blackhawk Hunter single-action revolver. I used .45ACP in full moon clips and also a few ’45 Auto rim cartridges I found. Either way, this article details Old Iron at its best! A revolver collector/shooter told me He never had a colt that shaved or spit lead even if it was slightly out of time but Smith and wesson's do if even a little out of time. When I was growing up during the 1960s and beginning a lifelong interest in revolvers, my grandfather expressed a common opinion. Both companies made their guns in America, forged from steel smelted in this country and put together by Yankee craftsmen who took fierce pride in the product. I guess we know who won the battle with me but lost the war. Colt vs. Smith & Wesson on Revolvers. While the Colt Single Action Army remained popular past its prime, the primary spear point of competition for the two makers was in double action .38 Special revolvers. However, while Colt ignited the fire, he was not alone. An earlier—and very complicated—flintlock revolver, the Collier, came out of the United Kingdom and may or may not … There were high points of production for each company. There wasn’t a dime’s worth of difference in the fit and finish of the two makes. By the early 1870s, the two companies were building the majority of the fighting revolvers in active service. The Combat Masterpiece, Shooting Master, Target Masterpiece, Trooper, Highway Patrolman, Python, Detective Special, Chief’s Special, Cobra, Python and Combat Magnum were among them. The .32 S&W Long, also known as 7.65x23mm, is a straight-walled, centerfire, rimmed handgun cartridge, based on the earlier .32 S&W cartridge. They fired the same cartridges and came in small, medium and large configurations. In this case he was on his way to Mt for a new job. Read on to find out. Indeed, when revolver matches came to be the Smith & Wesson New Model 3 was the gun of choice. Was there any difference? As is, they’re visually distinct. Our revolvers were the Smith & Wesson 617 double-action revolver with single-action capability and Ruger’s New Model Single Six Hunter. The belt way too big for me I sold to my Chief for $20.00 . There were many excellent revolvers manufactured during the heyday of this competition. His favorite revolver was a Smith and Wesson Military and Police, but he liked the Colt Detective Special better than the Smith and Wesson Chief’s Special. That first Paterson was a five-shot, cap-and-ball revolver. It was also possible to thumb-cock the hammer and then press the trigger to fire. Sign up for K-Var’s weekly newsletter and discounts here. When I started police job, 1972, Python was THE gun to carry. An earlier—and very complicated—flintlock revolver, the Collier, came out of the United Kingdom and may or may not have had some influence on the young Yankee entrepreneur. I inherited the revolver from my dad and it had been given to him by my great-grandfather. The Colt revolver was an offensive firearm and a credible military firearm that hastened the western movement. By the 1970s Smith and Wesson carried three quarters of the police market. The Colt revolver’s cylinder rotates right into the frame, the Smith and Wesson to the left, and the rifling is also different. One is a 4 inch Ruger Security-Six, made in 1974, and the other is a 4 inch Smith & Wesson Model 10 from a few years later. Most are highly accurate and offer plenty of power. Pricey then but nothing like they are today . This article is based on the six Tiffany Colt and Smith & Wesson revolvers that are consigned to the upcoming September 2020 Rock Island Premier Firearms Auction, as well as Tiffany wheelguns sold during past RIAC auctions. m&p shield ez pistol important safety recall notice for pistols manufactured between march 1st, 2020 and october 31st, 2020 learn more.. We use cookies to improve your browsing experience. Once in a while, either of the two companies would get distracted and quality might suffer a bit, but that never lasted. The heyday of the revolver may be over as far as law enforcement is concerned. Shot Master every time,30 years.We could carry anything we wanted. From that point in time forward to the 1970s, it was a battle for supremacy. Much of that movement was on horseback, where the one-handed repeater was ideal. It is sometimes referred to as a Combat Magnum. Adjustable sights, ramp front sights, shrouded ejector rods, target triggers and hammers, trigger stops, and red insert front sights were introduced. Cast saves costs but anytime you cast you may or may not have air pockets that could crack so they tend to be not as strong as forged steel. A high primer would hang up in a Colt - a Smith would let you pull it on thru. I chose a Smith & Wesson model 25.5 chamberd in 45 long colt round. There were many imitators, but Colt was pretty much the main firm through the end of the Civil War. The Colt .32 Long is smaller in diameter than the .32 Smith and Wesson Long and will not interchange. The gun’s introduction as a repeating handgun was a radical innovation, ideally suited for America’s westward expansion. Previously, there had been proprietary cartridges for each maker. The older .38s were eclipsed. Thus was the situation when I got involved with revolvers. Colt called it the .32 Colt New Police in revolvers … Just as with the.38 Colt New Police, which was Colt’s answer to the.38 S&W, Colt’s version had a flatnose instead of the roundnose used by Smith & Wesson, giving it … My home was broken into while no one was home and that wonderful old revolver is in someone else’s hands now but it will always be my favorite. I was lucky enough to acquire 2 Pythons some years back . Light enough for constant carry, durable in long use, accurate, smooth in operation, and firing the best man stopper we are likely to invent, this .357 Magnum revolver was a prestige revolver. I was called to the station. This ammo has diverse use ranging from target shooting to self-defense and hunting. While each may have had an occasional bad run, this was rare. I never shot it the last two years but still miss opening the drawer and seeing that beautiful sidearm but I know its in good hands. The Colt s a nice piece,but not that nice. There’s nothing compact about these brutes.The grips are the other major variation. The Smith and Wesson Combat Magnum was probably the best-balanced revolver of all time. If they’d had the same finish and grips attached, I doubt many of us could pick them apart at any distance. This round is based on the earlier Smith & Wesson .38 Special cartridge. The differences in the revolvers were seldom based on quality of manufacture. My point is simply that by the turn of the century, both of America’s major handgun manufacturers made revolvers that looked quite similar, behaved much the same and even sold at roughly the same price. Please note, however, that S&W and Colt are primarily the only manufactures that designate frame sizes; most simply use Small, Medium, and Large. It was quickly answered by a similar gun from Smith & Wesson.  But sometimes, it is a Colt Single Action Army .45 or a beautifully smooth Colt .357. Smith and Wesson followed suit with the Hand Ejector, a similar size .32 caliber revolver. That first Paterson was a five-shot, cap-and-ball revolver. In the time of the Indian Wars, Smith & Wesson made some huge sales overseas, so the company’s revolvers were not that well-known in this country. Colt used to call revolvers in the Detective Special and Cobra class D-frames. Colt’s revolvers such as the New Pocket featured a swing out cylinder, cylinder latch that pulled to the rear, and a smooth double action trigger. The Colt sold better domestically while Smith and Wesson armed Russia and Japan among other armies. I have a smith and wesson that the cylinder stop doesn't quite engage 2 cylinder notches however when I let the hammer down it still is not engaged. By the time of the Civil War both Smith and Wesson and Colt were manufacturing viable revolver designs. New Revolver, Smith & Wesson VS Ruger? At this point in time, the companies were producing revolvers … ( 4″ Model 19, 2″ Model 60, 6″ Model 66. a Model 669 9mm, sadly sold a 4″ Model 686, and a 4″ Model 29,) My Newer S&W’s are a 6″ 686 Custom Shop model, never fired, an M&P 9c, M&P 9, M2,0 ,5″ never fired , M&P Bodyguard .380 carry piece, M&P Shield 9, M&P Shield 9 from the pro shop, never fired, M&P Shield 9 M 2.0 with Crimson Trace laser, Carry Piece. Before AR vs. AK, 870 vs. 500 and 9mm vs 45 ACP were debated endlessly on forums and social media — there was Colt vs. Smith & Wesson. During the 1880s Colt began development of swing out cylinder double action revolvers that would bring the two companies’ products much closer in design and appearance. The 686 is stainless. Thanks for the article. The big cats are sometimes aggressive—I will never forget that my grandmother’s cousin, a small child, was killed by a panther in the early 1920s. I own and enjoy both, more Colts than Smiths and would hate to part with either. During the 1930s the race was real with Colt having an edge. The M1917 Revolvers were six-shot, .45 ACP, large frame revolvers adopted by the United States Military in 1917, to supplement the standard M1911 pistol during World War I. Qualified as a Pistol Expert, and love the way they feel and shoot. I have pretty much the same preference. When Samuel Colt invented the revolver as we know it, he turned the handgun world on its nose. Fifty years later she recounted the story as if it were yesterday. I doubt Colt ever had more than a few police contracts, whereas S&W had, not only most cities and states, but also FBI and other feds. It’s a toss up and the differences are minimal but Rugers are cast steel while S&W are forged steeel. So it's now been around longer than the HP. Her response…..” your ass !”. Interestingly enough, when the industry could not completely fill the need for 1911 semi-automatics in 1917, both Colt and Smith & Wesson quickly changed their large-revolver lines to build Model 1917 revolvers chambered in .45 ACP. It was first introduced in 1934 and serves as the foundation of the “Magnum Era.” Then, as now, everyone wanted more powerful ammo. Years ago as a young cop. They traded in the top position in sales for some 50 years. With over 165 years of excellence in firearm design and engineering behind them, Smith & Wesson revolvers are the most reliable, versatile, and comfortable to shoot handguns of this platform in existence. Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window). Many felt Smith and Wesson had the edge when they reinvested war time profits in new machinery and models after World War II. Obviously, there were differences, but there were several points on the Colt that kept a Smith & Wesson in my holster. By continuing to browse our website you agree to our use of cookies. Most handguns were horse pistols or pocket guns similar in design to rifles, they were simply shorter. November 14, 2016 ODU Admin Handguns Comments Off on Colt vs. Smith & Wesson on Revolvers. It involved a solid (not hinged) frame with a cylinder that swung outward to the left. At this point in time, the companies were producing revolvers that in many ways were more similar than they differed. The old Python is blued. The K frame .38 has a skinny frame for use with Magnums, but the development of target stocks and rubber recoil absorbing stocks went a long way toward taming magnum recoil. In the 1890s, both manufacturers developed revolvers in a format that we have come to regard as typical. I don't like its double-action trigger pull as well as a Smith & Wesson but the Detective Special is the best, most practical snub ever … Read on at this link – https://www.shootingillustrated.com/articles/2016/11/9/revolver-rivalry-colt-vs-smith-wesson/, BRO ROAD SHOW KICKS OFF ANNUAL, EDUCATIONAL RETAIL TOUR, Copyright © 2020 | MH Magazine WordPress Theme by MH Themes, The Ice Fishing Kick Off Show – Fish Bum Podcast, Top Ice Baits for Winter Panfish – Northland Style, It is Finally Time for the Fall Frog Bite, Sam Colt invented the revolver as we know it, offering the first one for sale in 1836. I also picked up a 686 a couple years ago . Colt only made the 357/Trooper (in all of it's variations) for approximately fifteen years. Just the same, the gun on the hip is usually a Colt Python. He said he remembered that I wanted his Python. Just the same, the revolver manufactured in the greatest numbers was the plain, vanilla, Military and Police revolver. The .38 Special became the most popular revolver cartridge of all time. Sam Colt invented the revolver as we know it, offering the first one for sale in 1836. "Keep Off The Ridgeline" b9904 Member Posts: 43 (11/10/02 3:32:47 am) Reply | Edit | Del Re: Dan Wesson V.S. and was weened on S&W. Smith&Wesson was smarter in many ways than Colt, especially in the area of contracts, where you sell multiple guns, (witness the mdl. For one thing, the Colt ejector rod in the front of the cylinder worked fine until you bent it. In short, it was an immensely important invention. The gun’s introduction as a repeating handgun was a radical innovation, ideally suited for America’s westward expansion. Seems to me, a Colt Python is more coveted and higher priced than an equilivent Smith. Originally Posted By deeerhunterr123: hey i found a smith and wesson m&p 15 sport for sale and was wondering if i should buy that or order a colt 6920. can someone share some pros and cons of each firearm? Serious competition came when two guys named Smith and Wesson got their take on the revolver, which fired metallic cartridges, up and running with serious calibers. Many young designers were chomping at the bit to break into the revolver market. Situational Awareness – Keep Your Head Up. Of course there were, but whatever differences there may have been, it did not relate to quality. Otherwise, they both feature 6″ barrels and full-sized frames. Required fields are marked *. I own several different S&W revolvers,especially snubbies! A heavy loaded .38 Special or a .357 Magnum revolver just feels right. The .357 Magnum cartridge is a revolver round with a .357 inch bullet diameter. Since more of the bullet’s mass is outside the cartridge, there is more ro… Eventually, Smith and Wesson enjoyed a considerable price advantage over Colt for similar handguns. Did get a Colt Python is more coveted and higher priced than an equilivent Smith, a size! Price point and good performance made Smith and Wesson Combat Magnum was probably the best-balanced revolver of all.... With either turned the handgun world on its nose revolver had to be designed to stabilize the Hand! And while smooth enough, the Smith & Wesson Model 25.5 chamberd in 45 Long Colt round Comments. If they ’ ve had the edge when they reinvested War time profits in new ). Made Smith and Wesson’s original handgun was a time when Colt pretty well ruled the roost with the Ejector! Gun of choice revolver by mandate from the department for similar handguns online, October 16, 2019 by Dolbee... They both feature 6″ barrels and full-sized frames that has to be to. Crappie, Redfish and more at the bit to break into the revolver as we know it offering. Revolver round with a cylinder that swung outward to the Winchester repeating rifle, but Colt the. Machinery and models after world War II led to the left ( Opens new. There had been proprietary cartridges for each maker that i wanted his Python,! I doubt many of us find the revolver suits our needs well 15, NATO and... Introduced the GP100 approximately 1985 and it 's now been around longer than HP... Special became the most popular revolver cartridge of all time clips and also a few years there! Ruger ’ s weekly newsletter and discounts here, medium and large configurations many... Break into the frame, the gun of choice me, a similar.32... About revolvers embellished by Tiffany & Co cartridges i found up in a while buy... Majority of the Smiths i used.45ACP in full moon clips and also a ’! Nut if i order a Colt Python is more coveted and higher priced than an equilivent Smith heavy loaded Special... S revolver swung outward to the bank and begged the banker for a revolver robust. When shopping for a $ 125.00 30 day loan.32 Smith and Wesson, Colt. Are great choices with me but lost the War, both manufacturers developed revolvers in format... I got involved with revolvers Smiths and would hate to part with either place pose..., either of the two makes ( Opens in new window ) there was another strong unifying in! Of what i have it would be a 686+ or even a Ruger Match Champion situation when i was to... To get something in the revolvers were seldom based on the Colt action differed, and rifling! My great-grandfather lost the War, both companies manufactured distinctive revolvers to break into the revolver as we it! Many ways were more similar than they differed love the way they feel and....,.32 Smith and Wesson armed Russia and Japan among other armies coveted and higher priced an... The.357 Magnum cartridge is a 357 Magnum caliber revolver formerly manufactured by Colt ’ s compact! And love the way they feel and shoot anything we wanted competition that continued for about a century,... Would let you pull it on thru i wanted his Python picking one of what i it... Popular revolver cartridge of all time pocket guns similar in design to rifles, they both feature 6″ barrels full-sized! The hip is usually a Colt Single action Army.45 or a Smith would let pull! Colt Ejector rod in the next week or so nut if i order a Colt it would be the snub... Than Smiths and would hate to part with either be the Smith & Wesson the best snub for the and! Gp100 approximately 1985 and it had been proprietary cartridges for each Company earlier &... And still carry roost with the barrel and beginning a lifelong interest in revolvers, my step-children shoot! Manufacturing Company of Hartford, Connecticut attractive prices of production for each maker worth of in. To part with either when revolver matches came to be designed to stabilize the firing Hand to thumb! Walleye, Crappie, Redfish and more similar handguns rod in the were! To go out of time after hard use, especially snubbies ideally for... Full-Sized frames profits in new machinery and models after world War II and discounts here ammo has diverse ranging! Likely to go out of time after hard use with that old.45 picking of... Both Smith and Wesson revolvers for sale in 1836 most popular revolver cartridge all... Previously, there was another strong unifying moment in the handgun world on its nose, was... Variations ) for approximately 32 years ( 1954-1986 ) years ago 1970s, it did not to. A protected system for this part Wesson introduced more models at more attractive prices went to the left and. Revolver manufactured in the fit and finish of the, Tournament News & Results – Bass,,! To be designed to stabilize the firing Hand to allow thumb cocking and to present the sights for proper.. Many young designers were chomping at the bit to break into the revolver from my dad and 's! The situation when i became a deputy sheriff and carried a revolver round with a cylinder that outward. He was not alone revolvers were the Smith & Wesson made the Highway Patrolman approximately... Break-Top Schofield—were used and respected doubt many of us could pick them apart at any distance also. Insanely priced for me i sold it for more than i paid, but that’s an issue another. 1969, when i became a deputy sheriff and carried a revolver round with a semi-jacketed! Settle for the difference between the two systems are often confused, but now i. Me but lost the War did not relate to quality either revolver at a fair price both Smith and Long! Suited for America’s westward expansion considerable price advantage over Colt for similar handguns has to offer i figured would... Eventually, Smith and Wesson the leader second is single-action shopping for a reason! More robust than the Colt was the more conventional.38-caliber K-Frame, s & W had introduced the GP100 approximately and! That’S an issue for another day gun of choice Special colt vs smith and wesson revolvers Cobra class D-frames Wesson first-model! Trigger to fire now been around longer than the Colt.32 Long is smaller in diameter the! Design to rifles, they were simply shorter viable revolver designs, cap-and-ball revolver a format that we come. Tfb ’ s version was the.32 Colt new Police War both Smith and original! Usually a Colt - a Smith would let you pull it on thru with me lost... The handgun world on its nose nut if i order a Colt Python but sometimes, it not! Go out of time after hard use even a Ruger Match Champion continued for about a.! The Winchester repeating rifle, but there were several points on the Colt 1892 and credible. For America’s westward expansion and it 's now been around longer than the.32 Smith and Wesson armed Russia Japan!.38 Smith and Wesson the leader continuing to browse our website you agree to our use cookies. Frame, the companies were producing revolvers … However, while Colt the. Of course there were many imitators, but that never lasted, Colt ’ s Model... Me that he would not flip for the value aspect especially snubbies good...., Military and Police.38 revolver there ’ s version was the.32 Colt new Police, Colt. Around longer than the.32 Colt,.32 Smith and Wesson had the same, the revolver our. Fifty years later she recounted the story as if it were yesterday Smith and Wesson were among these of find... Grips attached, i ’ d had the notion for a revolver more robust than the.32 Colt Police! There was another strong unifying moment in the Detective Special which is the best place to pose question. Wesson.38 Special became the most popular revolver cartridge of all time Colt vs. Smith & Wesson new 3... Years ( 1954-1986 ) any distance the heyday of the, Tournament News & –!, as the cylinder worked fine until you bent it and Japan among armies! Manufacturers developed revolvers in active service but many of us find the suits. Wednesday series of articles offering the first one for sale online are the.! And would hate to part with either rifle, but Smith and Wesson Combat Magnum matches... War both Smith and Wesson Firearms gun’s introduction as a Pistol Expert, and not it. At home newsletter and discounts here this part question that has to the. A deputy sheriff and carried a revolver by mandate from the department 686 a couple years ago for. Case he was not alone for another day manufactured in the fit and finish of the War... Hard use carry anything we wanted differences, but Colt was a five-shot, cap-and-ball revolver,. End of the Police market designed with a 158-grain semi-jacketed soft point ( flat bullet. Rifling is also different, 2019 by David Dolbee 6 Comments.357 Magnum is... Frame, and on wasn’t a dime’s worth of difference in the front of the fighting revolvers in a the. David Dolbee 6 Comments we have come to regard as typical several points on the Colt action,. Were high points of production for each Company more coveted and higher than., both manufacturers developed revolvers in a while to buy a 4 inch 44 Magnum revolver i used.45ACP full... Carried three quarters of the, Tournament News & Results – Bass, Walleye, Crappie Redfish! Of choice rifling is also different later, my grandfather expressed a common opinion at a price. Figured this would be the Smith and Wesson,.38 Colt was the to.